寄付 2024年9月15日 – 2024年10月1日 募金について

Topology: A Geometric Approach

Topology: A Geometric Approach

Terry Lawson
この本はいかがでしたか?
ファイルの質はいかがですか?
質を評価するには、本をダウンロードしてください。
ダウンロードしたファイルの質はいかがでしたか?
Main subject categories: • Topology • Geometry

I agree with the reviewer before me: this book sets the bar for poor mathematical exposition. Its passages are little more than shoddily constructed rambles.
The tragedy is that Lawson does have some interesting ideas about how to approach topology. His geometric emphasis can indeed provide useful intuition, while "projects" contained in the supplementary exercises are engaging and provide useful experience.
But the good pedagogical concepts underlying his work do not excuse the terrible writing that fills it. In fact, no word better characterizes Lawson's Topology than "lazy". As the previous reviewer mentioned, Lawson has an almost pathological habit: he writes pages of non-rigorous and poorly justified arguments, then literally "leaves the details as an exercise." These "details" are frequently tedious computations unrelated to topology. Meanwhile, the "proofs" often aren't proofs at all; they nebulously cite previous arguments ("we can adapt the argument of section X.XX") in a way that mires the reader in page-turns and confusion. Such garbage has made my classmates -- some of the best students at a top-10 university known for its undergraduate math -- uniformly revile this text.
I'll make my advice simple: if you are a self-learner, do not buy this book. If you are a professor, do not use it. If you are Terry Lawson, halt the publication of this mess until you can make it useful.

巻:
9
年:
2006
版:
1
出版社:
Oxford University Press [OUP]
言語:
english
ページ:
404
ISBN 10:
0199202486
ISBN 13:
9780199202485
ISBN:
B01K0T15YA
シリーズ:
Oxford Graduate Texts in Mathematics [OGTM]
ファイル:
PDF, 5.42 MB
IPFS:
CID , CID Blake2b
english, 2006
オンラインで読む
への変換進行中。
への変換が失敗しました。

主要なフレーズ